top of page

Cryptedge Consults #005 | SEC’s Legal Action against Coinbase, Binance, and Others: An Analysis

Introduction: The Regulatory Storm

This month, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) initiated significant legal action against leading cryptocurrency entities, including Coinbase, Binance , and others. This unprecedented enforcement action signaled a seismic shift in the SEC's approach to crypto assets, making clear the agency's intent to apply traditional securities laws to this innovative sector.

In its arguments, the SEC asserted that certain offerings by these companies constituted securities and thus were subject to federal securities laws. In particular, Coinbase's Lend program, which guaranteed a fixed return on assets, was interpreted by the SEC as a security. This perspective was unequivocally articulated in the SEC's notice against Coinbase, claiming that the Lend program should have been registered as a security.

The Howey Test: The Bedrock of the SEC's Argument

The cornerstone of the SEC's legal action is the application of the Howey Test, a rule that originated from a 1946 Supreme Court case. According to this test, a transaction represents an investment contract, or a security, if "a person invests his money in a common enterprise and is led to expect profits solely from the efforts of the promoter or a third party."

While the Howey Test provides a general framework, its application to the multifaceted and complex world of crypto assets can be tricky. However, the SEC has remained steadfast in using this test to evaluate whether a cryptocurrency product or token should be classified as a security.

Accounting Irregularities: The Hidden Culprit of the Crackdown

Another essential aspect of the SEC's action was the charge of accounting irregularities and derivations from best practices. In charging this point, the agency contended that these companies were not following US Generallt Accepted Accounting Principles. Namely, by using blockchain technology to record and verify transactions, these companies were evading traditional financial oversight and accountability.

Although blockchain technology offers many benefits, such as transparency and security, its use in financial transactions is still relatively novel. The SEC's guidance states that these entities must adhere to standard accounting procedures, irrespective of the technology they use.

The Aftermath: Industry-Wide Ripples

The SEC's actions sent shockwaves throughout the crypto industry, resulting in a massive shift in operations. Crypto exchanges began assessing their services for regulatory compliance, while blockchain projects initiated audits to ascertain they weren't inadvertently issuing securities.

The outcomes of these measures have been a mixed bag. On one hand, they have instigated greater market volatility and investor unease due to fears of additional regulation. On the other hand, these actions have also led to improved transparency and standardization in the industry, potentially paving the way for wider adoption of cryptocurrencies.

As for the implicated companies, they faced severe legal and financial repercussions. Hefty fines were imposed, and their operations were significantly disrupted. For example, Coinbase was forced to suspend its lending program, while Binance had to make substantial modifications to its derivatives offerings.

Looking Ahead: A Crossroads for the Cryptocurrency Industry

The SEC's actions against Coinbase, Binance, and other cryptocurrency entities mark a critical juncture in the crypto industry's evolution. It's a crossroads where the decentralized ethos of cryptocurrencies meets the regulatory demands of traditional financial systems.

While the measures may seem punitive, they could potentially lead to more standardized, transparent, and secure trading practices.

In the wake of the SEC's legal actions against Coinbase, Binance, and other prominent cryptocurrency entities, the need for reliable accounting and compliance services within the crypto industry has never been more apparent.

Chat with us if you have any concerns over the regulatory or financial status of your business, so that these investigations by the Federal government continue to be on the least important end of regulatory risk for you and your stakeholders.

17 views0 comments


bottom of page